I thought my church would welcome me when I came out - but the reaction was very different
Simon Brooke, a Diverse Church trustee, shares a conversation with a young LGBTQIA+ Christian about her experience of rejection by her church

I’m always pleased to see a new face in the congregation of my local church and, as a warden, I see it as an important part of my job to say “hello.”
This particular young woman had been coming regularly for a few weeks when I took the opportunity after a service to catch her before she left and ask if she’d like to join the other members of the congregation for coffee. For a moment she seemed uncertain but then agreed.
“Do you live around here or are you just visiting?” I asked, as I always do.
“I actually live nearby,” she said. I mentioned that I did too, and then I asked her what brought her to our church.
Again, it’s a standard question and it often opens up some interesting conversations about faith and life experience. This time, though, it was different. The young woman blinked back tears.
“I’m so sorry,” I said. “I completely understand if you don’t want to talk about it.”
Still overcome with emotion, she shook her head.
“No, I’d like to talk about it if you don’t mind,” she said.
So, we found a quiet space in the garden away from the rest of the congregation and she told me her story. She’d had a strong and growing Christian faith since university. It had helped her get through some difficult times such as the death of her father as well as giving her life meaning, she explained, as she sipped her coffee. She’d even considered ordination but had decided, instead, to go into social work.
In her first job she had found herself working closely with another woman. They had got on very well both professionally and socially. One evening they had gone out for a drink after work and they soon realised that they had feelings for each other.
“We started dating,” she told me. “I’d had boyfriends before, but this was different. It felt so right. I was so happy and, a few months into our relationship, we moved in together. Sharing my first home with my partner was wonderful. My mother took a while to come to terms with my sexuality, but she was OK when she saw how happy I was.”
Because her Christian faith was such an important part of this young woman’s life, she decided to introduce her girlfriend to her fellow members of the church that she’d attended for the last few years.
“They were such lovely people, and we got on so well that I was sure they’d be happy for me, even if they might have been a bit surprised,” she explained.
In fact, the reaction was very different.
“As soon as they realised that she was not just a friend, even before I’d introduced my partner properly, their reaction changed,” she remembered. “They were cold and standoffish. The following Sunday, when I went to the usual service, alone this time, the priest took me aside afterwards. He asked me never to bring my girlfriend to church again. ‘I know you can’t help how you are,’ he explained, ‘and I’ll pray for you to be saved from this.’”
“I was shocked beyond words. This church was my spiritual home, and I’d always felt so comfortable here. But then, looking back I began to see how in the priest’s sermons and the comments by other people there had been subtle digs at gay people and those who were not, as they would put it, following the straight and narrow. I never went back there.”
We sat and silence for a moment. Then, when I felt the time was right, I said to her:
“Look, you are very welcome here as a gay woman. I’m gay as well. You might have seen the rainbow flag on the noticeboard when you came in.” She nodded. “At this Church we believe that God loves all his children whatever their sexual identity or orientation.”
I’m glad to say that this young woman has now become a regular member of our congregation and frequently brings her partner to church.
“We both feel so welcome,” she said to me recently.
As a gay Christian myself, this young woman’s story really resonates with me. For me, the gay thing came before the Christian thing. I realised that I was gay in my early teens. It was a disturbing and depressing revelation. I didn’t believe in God, but, somehow, I was still angry with Him for making me this way.
I was still struggling with my sexuality when I began to experience the emergence of a Christian faith. My family had never been churchgoers and had no interest in religion but from somewhere came the urge to go to church and to learn more about God.
I’m so glad I did because it’s added so much to my life.
Shortly after I met my husband, I began to come to terms with my sexuality. He helped me to understand and overcome the negative feelings I had. Today, I don’t see any conflict between being gay and being a Christian.
For some Christians, though, this idea can be a challenge. This might be because they’ve come to this conclusion themselves. Or, as in the case of the young woman that I’ve talked about here, because someone else has told them that being gay and Christian are incompatible.
For these people, and anyone exploring faith, sexuality and / or gender identity elements of their identities, Diverse Church is here for you. DC also has a parents group, for parents of LGBTQIA+ young people, and a Facebook site. Details of how to join are below.
This story is a combination of real life examples. Details have been changed to preserve anonymity.
Reach out to us to find out more about Diverse Church here
Visit our Facebook page


